
SandpapergateâÂÂs âÂÂwar of the ghostsâ highlights perils of relying on recall
One of Pat Cummins or Usman Khawaja must be lying about Cape Town? Not so, says a professor of memory
In 1932, the English psychologist Frederic Bartlett used cricket as a metaphor for memory. âÂÂWhen I make the stroke I do not, as a matter of fact, produce something absolutely new and I never merely repeat something oldâ he wrote in his landmark book Remembering: A Study in Experimental and Social Psychology.
Bartlett posited that remembering the past is just like playing a stroke, a cover drive say, in cricket. You can never repeat the stroke exactly, so like a fingerprint or snowflake, no two cover drives are exactly the same, even when played by the same person. Each cover drive is âÂÂmanufacturedâ afresh in the new circumstances, the âÂÂschemata of the moment and their interrelationsâÂÂ.
âÂÂItâÂÂs very fitting that Bartlett chose cricket as his example,â says Prof John Sutton. âÂÂWhat heâÂÂs saying is that when we remember something, we are always manufacturing a version of the past, even when we think we are just pulling out an isolated event from some library in our mind itâÂÂs not at all the case. YouâÂÂre retouching, youâÂÂre retelling, youâÂÂre reconstructing a version of past events.âÂÂ
Sutton describes himself as a âÂÂScots-AussieâÂÂ. He is Leverhulme International Professor and director of the Centre for the Sciences of Place and Memory at the University of Stirling, having spent most of his life working at Macquarie University in SydneyâÂÂs northwestern suburbs. He has just touched down in Sydney when we speak, amid the latest swirl of sandpaper headlines and newsreels, to begin work on a research project.
ItâÂÂs also important to say he was speaking before Cameron BancroftâÂÂs newspaper column on Wednesday in which he claimed the entire Australian Test team knew about the use of sandpaper during the 2018 Test tour of South Africa, and the subsequent response from Pat Cumminsâ management team which said there was nothing in the Bancroft statement that hadnâÂÂt been answered in Cumminsâ press conference where he denied any knowledge.
He speaks for plenty of Australians and wider cricket fans when he describes the pervading âÂÂsense of sadnessâ in watching the relationships of current and former players, notably Pat Cummins and Usman Khawaja, torn apart by the saga. The prevailing view among commentators and the general public is that one of the two must be lying about what happened in South Africa in 2018.
âÂÂI just strongly disagree with that,â says Sutton. âÂÂI think eight years is actually a hell of a long time, but even at the time people were experiencing different things. The emotional significance of what they were facing was different. ItâÂÂs perfectly possible that thereâÂÂs nobody involved here whoâÂÂs not telling the truth as they see it.âÂÂ
So it is perfectly possible that neither man is lying? âÂÂAbsolutely,â replies Sutton. A second or two passes. âÂÂBut itâÂÂs absolutely possible that one of them is. Or that both of them are.â Ah.
âÂÂBut itâÂÂs no surprise that peopleâÂÂs recollections differ. ThatâÂÂs both because of what happened then in memory â we call this the time of encoding â and whatâÂÂs happening now â we call this the time of retrieval.
âÂÂEven if a player has kept a diary of what happened at the time they are still retrieving a narrative, a sequence of events, from the past. That just doesnâÂÂt come out in a block with the sequence perfectly laid out from start to finish. ItâÂÂs even more complicated when youâÂÂre working with other people in recounting memories.âÂÂ
Sutton is a cricket fan and was actually in Cape Town watching the infamous 2018 Newlands Test with his dad and some friends. WeâÂÂre verging on Christopher Nolan territory when he confesses that he vividly remembers feeling that âÂÂsomething was offâ with the general mood and body language of the Australian players during South AfricaâÂÂs second batting innings, long before the images of Bancroft stuffing the sandpaper down his trousers appeared on the big screens in the ground. âÂÂWe had a feeling that the team were dealing with something other than what was directly facing them.âÂÂ

That is a perceptive group of cricket fans right there. Presumably Sutton is confident that he and his group havenâÂÂt co-opted and retrofitted this memory?
âÂÂOf course you have to ask that question and weâÂÂve asked it ourselves! We are confident we felt that way and discussed it well before the images were shown ⦠but, well, you start to see how tricky this stuff is.âÂÂ
There is a clear splintering between the batters and bowlers who were in the Australian dressing room in Cape Town. Both sides have former teammates and coaches backing their version of events unequivocally. This week presented the opportunity to tick both reserve fast bowler Chadd Sayers and then-assistant coach Graeme Hick off the bingo card.
Hick went on record to state that KhawajaâÂÂs claim that the entire dressing room was in on the plot is âÂÂabsolutely falseâÂÂ, while Sayers told the Australian radio station SEN: âÂÂEveryone in that side knew what was going on and what was being used. [Sandpaper] was used in two Test matches and there were discussions in the changing rooms.â Sayers stated that after the Cape Town Test match the entire team spent âÂÂ60-90 minutesâ in the changing rooms discussing what had happened.
How can the two groups have such differing recollections?
âÂÂRemembering the past together with other people can have good consequences and bad consequencesâ says Sutton. âÂÂOn the one hand, the reason that witnesses arenâÂÂt allowed to talk to each other before they go into court, say, when theyâÂÂve witnessed a crime, is that your story can get sort of condensed and converge and become a kind of fixed, rigid narrative that might encode some errors.
âÂÂBut also, collaboration can have a really good outcome if you get to kind of test your memories of events and how you feel about them, your emotions about events, against those of other people who might have a different take, who might have felt or experienced things differently.âÂÂ
Sutton explains that one thing that can happen with memories is the emotions associated with them can fester if theyâÂÂre not allowed some airing; if you donâÂÂt discuss or share them with people;donâÂÂt deal with them and keep them alive.
âÂÂWith events that are highly dramatic and highly significant and emotional, memory can get trapped and fixated.âÂÂ
Remember Frederic Bartlett? One of the memory experiments he conducted in 1932 was to get a group of participants to repeat a traditional Native American folktale to each other. He then traced how the memory of it changed with each retelling. The name of that story? War of the Ghosts. Now thatâÂÂs a better title than Sandpapergate.
-
This is an extract from the GuardianâÂÂs weekly cricket email, The Spin. To subscribe, just visit this page and follow the instructions.
