
A trio of experts has released a report casting doubt on whether convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein died by suicide in his jail cell in 2019, as a medical examiner in the United States previously ruled.
In documents obtained by Al Jazeera and other media outlets, Michael Freeman, Anders Eriksson and Itiel Dror â a forensic scientist, a forensic pathologist and a cognitive scientist â said the injuries on EpsteinâÂÂs body were âÂÂmost consistent with homicidal strangulationâÂÂ, not suicide.
Recommended Stories
list of 3 items- list 1 of 3Forensic experts claim Epstein was strangled to death
- list 2 of 3EpsteinâÂÂs death more likely homicide than suicide, forensic expert says
- list 3 of 3What do Deutsche Bank leaks reveal about Trump, Epstein and Russia?
âÂÂThe pattern, distribution, and multitude of injuries are not explained by a suicidal hanging,â their report reads.
Instead, they suggest Epstein was first assaulted and then strangled, providing an alternative narrative to the medical examinerâÂÂs 2019 report.
The cause of EpsteinâÂÂs death has long been a source of controversy and conspiracy theories.
A wealthy businessman, Epstein cultivated a range of high-profile relationships with leaders in politics, industry, academia and the arts. His network of contacts included US presidents Bill Clinton and Donald Trump.
Those connections have raised questions about whether there was a cover-up of EpsteinâÂÂs crimes â or whether some of his associates knowingly turned a blind eye.
In 2008, Epstein pleaded guilty to the solicitation of a minor for sex as part of a plea deal that saw him serve 13 months behind bars. Later, in 2019, he was arrested on federal charges of sex trafficking, with prosecutors accusing him of having âÂÂsexually exploited and abused dozens of underage girlsâÂÂ.
He died in a New York City jail while awaiting trial.
A controversy over cause of death
Medical examiner Kristin Roman performed the autopsy on EpsteinâÂÂs body. She and New York CityâÂÂs Chief Medical Examiner Barbara Sampson ultimately ruled that the evidence pointed to a suicide by hanging.
Other experts have sided with their ruling, pointing out that, while the circumstances of EpsteinâÂÂs death were unusual, they are not necessarily inconsistent with suicide.
But EpsteinâÂÂs brother, Mark, has long doubted the medical examinerâÂÂs findings. He gave Freeman, an Oregon-based forensic scientist, access to the death records.
Freeman has consulted in trials where families have questioned the narratives put forward by law enforcement about how someone died, including in high-profile cases like the murder of George Floyd.
Eriksson, meanwhile, is a Sweden-based forensic pathologist who has researched issues like shaken baby syndrome, a controversial diagnosis used to prosecute some adults for abuse of young children.
He and Freeman worked alongside Dror, a cognitive scientist who studies biases in forensic science.
At the time of his death, Epstein was a well-known figure, and Dror said the investigators handling his case would have been subject to significant political pressure.
âÂÂItâÂÂs so obvious this played a critical role in the examination of the body,â Dror told Al Jazeera.
âÂÂThere was at stake a lot of emotion, a lot of people involved, a lot of politics involved, so many factors. You can list them for an hour, and all of those interfered and biased and influenced what should be a scientific decision.âÂÂ
Dror explained that he and his colleagues pored over photos and records related to EpsteinâÂÂs death and concluded that the medical examiner had wrongly ruled it a suicide.
Points of concern raised
In their report, the trio noted a number of issues with the initial investigation.
The prison personnel who found EpsteinâÂÂs body did not take any photos before moving it, for instance. Investigators also failed to identify the ligature, the object that was actually around EpsteinâÂÂs neck, they said.
They allege that some avenues of investigation went unexplored. The prison guard who first came across EpsteinâÂÂs body initially refused to be interviewed, according to the report, and the medical examiner who determined the case was a suicide was not allowed to visit the prison.
The report also disagrees with the medical examinerâÂÂs assessment of EpsteinâÂÂs injuries.
Marks left by the ligature on EpsteinâÂÂs neck, the researchers said, were not slanted in the way that would be expected if his body had been hanging from the bedpost in his cell.
They observed bruising on EpsteinâÂÂs back, shoulder and neck that they said was not acknowledged in the medical examinerâÂÂs original statements.
Those injuries, their report said, are âÂÂmost consistent with homicidal strangulation from behind, most likely using a narrow knotted fabric ligatureâÂÂ.
Freeman, Eriksson and Dror believe either that the prison guard who found Epstein was lying about finding his body hanging in the cell, or that the body was deliberately put into that position to make it seem like a suicide had taken place.
