Cameron Bancroft and Pat Cummins
Not only does Cameron Bancroft’s statement imply that Pat Cummins’s press conference last Friday was an exercise in misdirection, but it goes considerably beyond what Usman Khawaja offered in Sabr. Composite: Guardian Pictures (via Getty)
Not only does Cameron Bancroft’s statement imply that Pat Cummins’s press conference last Friday was an exercise in misdirection, but it goes considerably beyond what Usman Khawaja offered in Sabr. Composite: Guardian Pictures (via Getty)

Cameron Bancroft’s excruciating depiction of being the sandpaper scapegoat means that Cricket Australia’s ordeal is far from over

It’s the silence of self-protection and the clamour for a patsy that are the most humiliating details of Bancroft’s screed, and point not just to a poor culture but a malign one, writes Gideon Haigh

Australia chose the right day to lose a home series to England. By the time many tuned in on Wednesday, the last Aussie pair were batting in a largely empty Bellerive Oval, Harry Brook was bowling his filth, the commentators were talking about how Jonathan Trott used to take centre, and nobody was paying the remotest attention. The whole affair seemed utterly beside an overpowering point.

Meanwhile, somewhere in Perth, Cameron Bancroft was beginning a few days’ quiet contemplation, having got a very great weight off his mind, and dropped it on the Australian cricket team. Not only does his statement imply that Pat Cummins’s press conference last Friday was an exercise in misdirection, but it goes considerably beyond what Usman Khawaja offered in Sabr, and Chadd Sayers added at the weekend. Did even they not grasp the extent of what was going on? We knew the Australian dressing room in 2017-18 was a toxic place, but was it this … confused?

That’s before we get into the detail. Khawaja, for example, has described Bancroft volunteering to sandpaper the ball in Port Elizabeth, almost eager, shrugging off cautions; Bancroft is equally explicit he “was asked whether I could carry out the task” and immediately “felt uncomfortable and compromised”. These aren’t minor differences. They testify to the divergent perspectives even of those who broadly agree.

As far as the bowlers are concerned, Bancroft offers this minor concession: “I recognise there is a distinction between knowing a ball is reversing, suspecting it has been altered and knowing specifically that sandpaper has been used.” But he also describes “regular, natural and organic conversations” with the pacemen, a sense on the field of “excitement about the movement we were getting” simultaneous with a sense that “something we all knew was wrong had become part of our effort”.

Australia’s David Warner, Steve Smith, Cameron Bancroft and Usman Khawaja
Australian cricketers David Warner, Steve Smith, Cameron Bancroft and Usman Khawaja in 2019. Photograph: Nick Potts/PA

These are jarring images, as is that of jovial Mitchell Marsh “joking about how much the ball was swinging and how he never used to swing it like that”. And there on our screens on Wednesday was none other than Marsh, the beaten skipper at the presentation, looking browbeaten as well.

The current Australian captain, it should be granted, is a slightly blurry presence in the statement. Cummins forms part of the ranks, perhaps as caught up as Bancroft, roughly the same age, in the general idea that anything went:

I never questioned the distinction between legitimate ball maintenance and deliberately altering the ball’s condition. But at the time, these practices were so normalised that I barely gave them a second thought.

This was the beginning of my journey in the Australian cricket team. We were ruthless and willing to do these sorts of behaviours and cross boundaries to give ourselves an advantage, to win.

But Cummins is mistaken if he thinks the statement of his manager, Neil Maxwell, will suffice: “Whilst we feel for Cam and everything he’s been through there’s nothing in the statement that hasn’t been answered by Pat in his press conference.” If anything, the uncompromising note Cummins struck at that marathon press conference appears to have shaken the tree. Last week, for example, Australia’s captain claimed not to recall “any conversation around collective responsibility” after 2018’s Cape Town Test. Bancroft’s account of a discussion of an apportionment of responsibility is contrastingly vivid.

After the match, I remember a lengthy meeting involving players and staff on the tour.

We discussed how to respond to the scandal and the information that would need to be acknowledged publicly. By then, it was clear that the use of sandpaper could no longer be concealed.

Nobody in that meeting stood up and said they had been completely unaware of my use of sandpaper. Not one person.

Contrary everyone started to give me advice about what I should say and what I shouldn’t say to minimise the damage on the team related with the sandpaper saga.

The scenario is excruciating. It’s the silence of self-protection, followed by the clamour for a patsy. If true, and it is a recollection coloured by emotion that’s bound to be contested, this is the screed’s most humiliating detail. Ball tampering: in the scheme of things, a second-order offence. Scapegoating: that’s not just a poor culture but a malign one.

Still, what to do when your own ostensible leaders seem to have failed so badly? Bancroft describes Steve Smith’s ultimately calamitous decision to front that fateful evening press conference as motivated by wanting “to clear it so he could focus on batting”. That is a very Smith moment: when in doubt, seek the solace of the crease. Bancroft’s description of the complicity of coaches Darren Lehmann and David Saker, meanwhile, is more damning even than Khawaja’s.

Bancroft’s statement does not cease with Sandpapergate, and the penultimate fourteen-paragraph section should not be overlooked. “The Career I Thought I Could Rebuild” describes Bancroft’s dwindling hope that suspension would somehow redeem him, that like Smith and David Warner he could work his passage back: “For many years I believed I would be selected because I trusted the selection process. But I would be lying if I said I had never wondered whether the unresolved tension surrounding these events in South Africa had played a part.”

Bancroft has been an excellent domestic batter. It’s hard to believe that Australia discriminated against him because of Sandpapergate: it was, after all, Justin Langer, his former state coach and a close friend, who omitted him the last time. But the wondering and the not knowing would smart.

Detractors, however, might do their own wondering: whether Bancroft would now be being so candid had he played, say, thirty or forty Tests. They will speculate that he lied in the first instance in his own longer-term interests as well as the team’s shorter-term ones, and ask why he is now to be believed.

For their own part, Cricket Australia said on Wednesday it respected that Bancroft had told his story, and that it would take time to consider his comments. Lehmann said he would do the same.

But time is ticking away. With the overwhelming feeling in Bancroft’s statement, it is impossible not to sympathise, even if it’s unclear his ordeal is over. Certainly Australian cricket’s is far from finished.

  • Gideon Haigh writes at Cricket Et Al, where a version of this article was originally published