
AI could be a bubble and is not yet making Australia more productive, Michele Bullock says
RBA governor says AI is âÂÂgreat white hopeâ but its adoption is so far adding to inflation, rather than economic growth
-
Get our breaking news email, free app or daily news podcast
The Reserve Bank governor said AI could be a bubble and there was no evidence it is making the economy more efficient, as the Albanese government claims the technology will solve AustraliaâÂÂs economic malaise.
Ahead of an expected interest rate rise next week Michele Bullock also said the slump in house prices was deeper than others in AustraliaâÂÂs recent history.
Resurgent oil prices and inflation are weighing on markets but US tech stocks surged on Monday after Facebook owner Meta debuted its new Muse AI agent and saw its shares rise 11%.
Bullock said a messy slump in tech values could hurt economic activity, speaking at a CEDA event in Sydney.
âÂÂAll central banks are a little bit worried about that,â Bullock said.
âÂÂSome people think itâÂÂs a bubble, some people donâÂÂt. I donâÂÂt have a particular view one way or the other, but itâÂÂs a risk that I think weâÂÂre watching.âÂÂ
Bullock said the RBA and its overseas colleagues believed AI was âÂÂthe great white hopeâ to make economies more productive but had seen little sign of any effect yet, with rapid adoption and investment in datacentres adding to inflation instead.
She cited research from the RBAâÂÂs South Korean counterpart that found employees adopting AI tended to produce the same output but work 1.5 hours less each week.
âÂÂ[While] people fiddle around and try and figure out what to do with this new technology, productivity actually can decline,â Bullock said. âÂÂBut once we reimagine our business processes⦠then you might see productivity take off.âÂÂ
The Australian governmentâÂÂs intergenerational report, released on Tuesday, relied on the potential âÂÂprofoundâ boost from AI in its projection that Australiansâ inflation-adjusted per-person economic activity would rise from $99,200 today to $157,300 by 2066.
The treasurer, Jim Chalmers, told the GuardianâÂÂs Australian Politics podcast: âÂÂItâÂÂs the most transformative thing that will happen in our lifetime.âÂÂ
The report assumed productivity would return to its long run level of improving by 1.2% a year, which economists have said appears unlikely. If productivity only rose by 0.8%, per-person activity would only hit $136,600 by 2066.
Bullock said on Tuesday: âÂÂMany have put it, âÂÂwell, itâÂÂs an unrealistic assumption, weâÂÂre not going to get that.â I guess the way IâÂÂm trying to think about it is, âÂÂOK, thatâÂÂs what weâÂÂve got to aim at.âÂÂ
Housing downturn
As the government defends AustraliaâÂÂs easing rate of immigration, Bullock said immigration was almost entirely responsible for AustraliaâÂÂs economic growth in the last year.
Bullock said new arrivals did not add to inflation as they typically worked as well as spending money. She said the exception was the housing market, as new immigrants did not immediately generate new housing supply.
âÂÂWhere it bites is the housing market, because the housing market canâÂÂt respond,â she said.
One Nation has called for more migrants to leave Australia than arrive over three years, including reducing the number of temporary migrants by more than 750,000.
Labor has instead planned to tighten the existing immigration intake, which home affairs minister Tony Burke said would be âÂÂpart of the solution for the housing crisisâ â but Burke warned more severe cuts could âÂÂtrash the economyâÂÂ.
House prices have fallen 3.1% over the past three months after the RBA lifted interest rates three times and the government reformed property investor tax breaks. Bullock said home loan approvals had slumped, in her most explicit public comments on the budget to date.
âÂÂTheyâÂÂve dropped for everyone but theyâÂÂve really dropped a long way for investors, so it has changed the dynamic for investors, whether itâÂÂs worth investing in housing or not,â she said.
Bullock said housing had become âÂÂpretty unaffordableâ before the decline, which she described as âÂÂa slight dip down after a very long run upâÂÂ.
âÂÂThe downturn is sort of in the lower range ⦠but itâÂÂs certainly not out of the ballpark of the sorts of downturns weâÂÂve seen in the past,â she said.
She declined to say whether she would recommend an interest rate increase next Tuesday. Traders are betting on more than a 90% chance rates will rise from 4.35% to 4.6%, which would be a 14-year high.
