The Pittsburgh Pirates sit at 21-37 forward of Saturday night time’s matchup in opposition to the San Diego Padres. Paul Skenes leads Don Kelly’s rotation in his second full season in Main League Baseball. Nevertheless, the Pirates and their ace face rumors surrounding a possible commerce away from the workforce. Skenes and Pittsburgh have shot the rumors, down, however former MLB common supervisor Jim Bowden put collectively one hypothetical commerce that may ship him out to the Crimson Sox in alternate for Roman Anthony and others.
Anthony has been dominant within the minor leagues in 2025, however has not been referred to as up but. The Crimson Sox have mentioned that they wish to give Anthony extra time to develop earlier than bringing them to the foremost leagues. Nevertheless, followers and Marcelo Mayer need Boston’s high prospect to get an opportunity with the workforce as quickly as attainable. If he does not get it with the Crimson Sox, he may discover it after the workforce trades him away.
Bowden instructed a package deal centered round Anthony if Skenes is, actually, obtainable. Giving up the group’s high prospect can be a troublesome tablet to swallow. Nevertheless, if they’ll put Skenes subsequent to Garrett Crochet for the following 5 seasons, it’s well worth the danger.
Proposed package deal: OF Roman Anthony, 2B/SS Franklin Arias, 1B/OF Justin Gonzales, RHP Luis Perales
“To begin the package deal, the Crimson Sox may supply Anthony, the highest position-player prospect in baseball, whom the Pirates may promote to the majors instantly, giving him an opportunity to win NL Rookie of the Yr this season,” Bowden mentioned concerning the Crimson Sox’s commerce package deal for the All-Star. “They’d additionally enhance their longer-term future by buying a center infielder in Arias, an influence bat in Gonzales and an influence arm in Perales. In the meantime, for Boston, a rotation led by Skenes and Garrett Crochet can be a game-changer.”
Why the Boston Crimson Sox ought to make the commerce
The Boston Crimson Sox introduced in Alex Bregman in the course of the offseason to spice up their offense. He joined 2024 All-Stars in Rafael Devers and Jarren Duran, forming a formidable trio on the plate. Whereas Triston Casas and Trevor Story are a few of Boston’s gamers which have fallen brief, the workforce’s offense is throughout the high 10 within the league. The Crimson Sox are additionally among the finest power-hitting groups within the league.
The place the workforce struggles is one the mound. Alex Cora’s beginning rotation is extraordinarily shaky behind Garrett Crochet. The 2025 American League Cy Younger candidate has been dominant, however Brayan Bello’s 3.83 ERA is one of the best Boston has except for Crochet. Skenes would are available and instantly kind among the finest pitching mixtures within the league.
He and Crochet each have ERAs below 2.20 forward of Saturday’s video games. Each are shoe-ins to earn spots on the All-Star workforce and will every be finalists for the Cy Younger award. Each aces are 25 years previous or youthful with the vast majority of their careers forward of them. If they’re this good already, they may very well be unstoppable collectively.
Giving up Anthony and different younger prospects leaves the Crimson Sox ready the place the gamers on their roster now should carry the workforce into the long run. Nevertheless, Bowden’s package deal leaves them with each Kristian Campbell and Mayer nonetheless on the roster.
Article Continues Under
Crimson Sox Commerce Grade: A
Why the Pittsburgh Pirates ought to make the commerce
The Pittsburgh Pirates are on the backside of the Nationwide League Central but once more. Skenes’ emergence as one of many recreation’s high starters has propelled the workforce into the nationwide highlight. Nevertheless, his teammates have been underwhelming. The 23-year-old took it upon himself to say that the accountability for the Pirates’ poor begin is on him and his teammates as a lot as it’s on the group.
Regardless of Skenes’ mature perspective, followers blame Kelly and administration for Pittsburgh’s efficiency to this point. Nevertheless, the workforce’s future seems to be extra in query than the rest. There are some consultants who marvel if the Pirates will open up their wallets and provides Skenes the long-term contract he’ll ask for when the time comes.
ESPN’s Jeff Passan doubts that the Pirates will select to maneuver Skenes relatively than pay him, however some doubt stays. This deal provides them items to construct round shifting ahead on the expense of their chief. This is able to not be the primary huge commerce centered round a younger star in skilled sports activities this yr, however the Pirates danger the identical backlash because the Dallas Mavericks acquired.
Buying and selling Skenes would save the Pirates cash and the Crimson Sox supply a future star within the discipline that might assist the workforce rebound. Anthony, Arias, and Gonzales would kind a brand new younger core together with Oneil Cruz as an alternative of Pittsburgh placing all of their hopes on Skenes’ shoulders. On the finish of the day, it’s a deal value listening to and contemplating.