
Rassie ErasmusâÂÂs tired ref-blaming act is wearing thin â South Africa deserve better
Springboksâ achievements are remarkable but their head coach lacks statesmanship, diplomacy and good grace in defeat
So here we go again. Exactly five years have passed since South AfricaâÂÂs head coach, Rassie Erasmus, first felt the full force of World RugbyâÂÂs ire for criticising match officials. And guess what? This most habitual of offenders has just copped another lengthy ban â and deservedly so â for his latest intemperate comments, notable as ever for their total lack of statesmanship, diplomacy or good grace in defeat.
To his acolytes his outspoken nature is part of what makes Rassie such a groot leier (great leader). To many others it simply cements his status as a serial prat. For the avoidance of any doubt everyone respects the remarkable achievements both of Erasmus and his double World Cup-winning teams. It is the rest of the package, sadly, that is too often a major letdown.
At times the Boksâ patron saint is almost reminiscent of Donald Trump in a tracksuit: crass, petulant and seemingly immune to the damage inflicted on the âÂÂlittle peopleâ who get in his way. How else to interpret his latest outburst after South AfricaâÂÂs defeat by France when he suggested that alleged incidences of foul play not picked up by either the referee or the television match official amounted to âÂÂmatch-fixingâ or âÂÂmanipulation of the gameâÂÂ?
Dissatisfied coaches are a familiar ingredient of the gameâÂÂs bubbling stew. And, yes, Erasmus technically has a point when he complains that several knee-drop tackles, recently classified as illegal, were missed in Paris. Rugby is a game of tiny margins and South Africa, as befits the worldâÂÂs No 1 nation, hate losing more than most.
But there is a much bigger picture involved and Erasmus remains seemingly incapable of appreciating the insidious toxicity of finger-pointing and ref-shaming in defeat. Back in 2021, when he embarked upon his 62-minute social media rant after the Boks had lost the opening Test of their series against the British & Irish Lions, he warned Berry he would publicise 36 refereeing errors if the official failed to meet him. The disciplinary panel found him guilty on six charges, imposed a lengthy ban from all matchday activities, and described his video as âÂÂan attack on the impartiality and integrity of the match officialsâÂÂ.
Berry, who will be in charge of EnglandâÂÂs game against New Zealand this weekend, duly attracted the online wrath of every keyboard warrior in South Africa and felt that âÂÂmy reputation as a referee and a person will forever be tarnished.â It did not stop Erasmus from being banned for two more matches the next year after his social media posts precipitated an internet pile-on for the English referee Wayne Barnes, also after a South African loss to France.
Which is why ErasmusâÂÂs latest outpourings, aimed at Matteo Liperini, the television match official in Paris, on the subject of multiple missed knee-drop tackles, were always going to be costly. âÂÂIâÂÂm saying if he didnâÂÂt see it, it must be a technology problem,â suggested Erasmus. âÂÂIf he saw it and decided not to act on it, is that not match-fixing?âÂÂ

Only in the eyes of a practised agent provocateur. Erasmus attended World RugbyâÂÂs refereeing summit in Windsor this month when the mantra of penalising only âÂÂclear and obviousâ indiscretions was repeatedly stressed, as was a desire to reduce the number of TMO referrals. Yes, there were some French tacklers who had knees on the ground as they hauled down Bok ball-carriers in the tumultuous final quarter in Paris but the refereeing team seemed to have decided they didnâÂÂt want a truly fabulous contest to be defined by some arbitrary late penalty.
It is possible to pour over any breakdown and find multiple things that could conceivably, by the letter of the law, be pounced upon. But, by the same token, none of it would have ultimately mattered had South Africa, with their scrum dominating, been minded to use any other instrument beyond the bludgeon.
It would have spared us all the tiresome âÂÂWhy always me?â whingeing that invariably resurfaces whenever northern hemisphere opponents or referees are involved. There were bound to be teething problems with the new hip-drop directive, hastily introduced from 1 November to bring rugby union into line with other contact sports. But to say that IrelandâÂÂs Sam Prendergast, cited for the offence after last weekendâÂÂs Fiji game, will escape punishment because double standards are at work? Talk about a victim complex.
Like all great conspiracy theorists, Erasmus is also only interested in selective facts that fit his preferred narrative. Of course he wants the refs to be vigilant when his team face Ireland this weekend; the strict letter of the law worked nicely for the Boks in Dublin last year. Of course he wants to spread the notion that South Africa may have been hard done in the Stade de France and deserve more sympathy this Saturday. He is by no means the only coach to operate in that way but his sledgehammer subtlety is in a league of its own.
Maybe in past years he, and his staunch defenders, could have blamed it on English being his second language. Such excuses, however, are long since redundant. To repeat, South Africa are a remarkable sporting nation and their rugby players remain first among equals. They deserve to be fronted by someone with rather more class.
