The SEC's new uniform NIL and revenue sharing agreements are causing an uproar among agents concerned that the conference has loaded the contracts with terms they consider unfair to student-athletes.
SEC presidents voted last month to adopt uniform NIL and revenue sharing contracts across the conference, joining the Big Ten as the second power conference to move toward a standardized contract.
Multiple agents told ESPN that they view the specifics of the uniform SEC contract as "way worse" than the one established in the Big Ten.
ESPN has reviewed a copy of the "NIL License Agreement" that SEC players and recruits are being presented with as schools work to get players with remaining eligibility re-signed for 2027 and the December signing period nears for high school prospects.
The standardized NIL agreements are another step toward a self-governance model within the SEC, something commissioner Greg Sankey has indicated could be necessary if Congress fails to enact federal legislation. The agreement drafted by the conference takes on issues such as tampering, transfers and buyouts as it sets the terms of student-athletes granting their rights to their school and conference.
The standardized contract is being met with serious pushback from players' agents, and sources told ESPN that several top agencies have informed schools that their clients will not sign the SEC contract with the current language.
Ryan Williams, an agent with Athletes First, referred to the SEC agreement in a post on X on Thursday as having "the worst contract language we've ever seen."
That stalemate is raising tensions for member schools as they pursue agreements with their star players and recruits. The SEC has several high-profile starting quarterbacks -- including Mississippi State's Kamario Taylor, Alabama's Keelon Russell and Vanderbilt's Jared Curtis -- who are in the process of negotiating new deals for 2027.
"Truthfully, I'm not negotiating with SEC schools until they fix this," one agent who represents nearly 30 SEC players and recruits told ESPN. "That's not a bluff. That's not an overexaggeration. I'm not doing this."
One agency told ESPN that it identified more than 20 issues with the SEC's uniform agreements, many of which it viewed as significant problems. Two SEC general managers told ESPN they were informed the schools have no latitude to alter the contract and that any redlining of proposed changes and revisions would need to be approved by the SEC office in a process that might take up to two weeks.
An SEC spokesperson said the conference did not have a comment at this time.
Sticking point: Transferring schools
Agents are concerned about much of the language around transferring. The SEC contract establishes liquidated damages for terminating the agreement at 50% of the remaining money on the agreement. It also allows schools to claw back a portion of money paid out as signing or retention bonuses, even for lump-sum payments at the start of the deal, from players who transfer or go pro. The buyouts are nonnegotiable.
Athletes cannot transfer from an SEC school to a new school until the buyout has been paid in full to their former school, and the new school must confirm it will count the buyout cost against its revenue-sharing cap. Damages would be due within 30 days.
SEC schools would not be required to enter an athlete into the NCAA transfer portal until after the final game of the final year of their agreement. The agreement also releases the school from its obligation to abide by NCAA notification-of-transfer bylaws requiring them to enter players' names in the portal upon request. Agents say this is one of the many details that raises major concerns about signing multi-year and back-loaded deals.
"Truthfully, I'm not negotiating with SEC schools until they fix this. That's not a bluff. That's not an overexaggeration. I'm not doing this." Agent, who represents nearly 30 SEC players and recruits, to ESPN
The agreement gives SEC schools broad authority to terminate the agreement, remove athletes from their team and then seek repayment plus liquidated damages. Schools can suspend or terminate the agreement if an athlete "engages in conduct that materially harms or is reasonably likely, in the good faith opinion of the Licensee, to materially harm the reputation, goodwill, or interests of Licensor, the NIL Rights, Institution, its affiliates, trustees, officers, employees, representatives, agents, students, alumni, fans, donors or sponsors."
Schools can also stop payments for a wide range of reasons, including when an athlete is suspended, arrested or charged with a crime, injured due to engaging in "dangerous activities," has excessive unexcused class or tutoring absences or fails to participate after being cleared by team doctors. Payments also depend on athletes being on the "active roster," which is not further defined in the agreement.
Other stipulations of uniform SEC contract
The SEC is also attempting to prohibit tampering and "impermissible contact" in its standard agreement. Athletes, their agents and representatives and anyone acting on their behalf cannot initiate, solicit, pursue or "engage in any oral or written communications or negotiations" with other schools before entering the transfer portal.
The prohibition includes agents disseminating their list of clients to other schools or anything else that intends to "signal or facilitate" an athlete's potential availability to transfer. This pre-portal contact, commonplace across the sport in the months leading up to the portal window opening in January, is a breach of the agreement and can trigger damages.
A school's obligation to pay the athlete ceases on the date a player publicly announces "or otherwise communicates through words or actions" an intent to enter the transfer portal, and schools can suspend or withhold payments pending investigation of any suspected breaches of the agreement.
Athletes must also submit any outside third-party NIL deals to their school for approval, and the school has 14 days and sole discretion to block or terminate any deals that may conflict with the school's "current or prospective" sponsorships, licensing or other commercial interests.
The last clause included in the SEC agreement addresses the Protect College Sports Act. If the PCSA or any other applicable laws are enacted and the school is exceeding a newly establishing spending cap, the school and athlete would have a 10-day period to renegotiate the agreement to bring it into compliance with the law. If those negotiations fail, the school can terminate the agreement with written notice.
"I think there's just a ton of issues with this contract that make it fundamentally unfair," another agent who represents roughly 20 SEC players and recruits told ESPN.
Agents frustrated
What's especially concerning to agents, though, is the response they've received when they've asked GMs about redlining and revising the standardized SEC agreement. One conference GM said he's received significant pushback but insists individual schools "don't have any latitude to make changes."
"They won't entertain a redline," one agent said. "The SEC has told them they're not allowed to redline."
Another agent said his experience so far has been that there's "basically no negotiating," even in attempts to add additional language that protects the athlete, such as an option to void the agreement if the player's head coach departs the program before a certain date.
"It makes no sense," he said. "The SEC agreement is like the Constitution and the NIL agreements might as well be written on a napkin."
SEC general managers had a meeting with the conference last week to discuss some of the specifics of the standardized agreement. They were told any proposed redlines needed to go through their school's general counsel and be sent to the SEC office, with the expectation they'd get a response within two weeks.
Agents and GMs agreed they're concerned about the implications of that stance as they rapidly approach the transfer portal window for college football opening on Jan. 4, and several told ESPN they wonder if the SEC contract could become a disadvantage for league members competing for top transfers.
One agent said he's not sure it will lead to decommitments from high school recruits to SEC schools, but he's confident it will "100% hurt them in the portal."
"I had an agent literally tell me, 'I'm not gonna send my players to SEC teams if it's even.' If it's Big Ten or us, they're going to the Big Ten," an SEC general manager said.
GM of SEC program: It's a 'real issue'
The Big Ten provided its member schools with a similar NIL license agreement template last year in preparation for the House settlement establishing revenue sharing in college athletics. Some sections of the conference's template agreement can be redlined and negotiated, two Big Ten GMs told ESPN. The strength of its agreement earned praise in January when Washington succeeded in preventing quarterback Demond Williams Jr. from transferring after he'd already re-signed with the school.
"The Big Ten contract is not my favorite, but it's way better," an agent said. "I truly don't think they're comparable. I honestly find this move to be the SEC saying, 'We want the power back.'"
Another SEC general manager told ESPN this is emerging as a "real issue" for front offices across the league and raises concerns the conference "just assumed they could do what they wanted and everyone would go along with it because they're the SEC."
The SEC also continues to consider imposing a luxury tax on members schools that spend more on players than the allotted revenue-sharing cap under the House settlement. ESPN reported earlier this month the SEC would like to approve the luxury tax before the early signing period begins on Dec. 2, though there's been much debate around the issue and specific levels of the luxury tax.
"You have high school deals that have been verbally agreed to, you have current player deals that you're trying to agree to, and we don't even know the rules yet," one SEC GM said.
ESPN's Alex Scarborough and Pete Thamel contributed to this report.
