Anthony Richardson‘s NFL profession hit one other pace bump in the course of the Indianapolis Colts‘ preseason recreation towards the Baltimore Ravens.
A dislocated pinky damage might sound minor, but it surely sparked recent questions in regards to the quarterback’s sturdiness heading into his third season.
The No. 4 general decide from the 2023 NFL Draft has but to show he is usually a dependable starter.
His struggles have drawn criticism from analysts who marvel if he has what it takes to succeed on the highest degree.
FOX Sports activities host Jason McIntyre just lately supplied a blunt evaluation of Richardson’s prospects.
“If you don’t suppose Anthony Richardson has the chops to be an NFL quarterback. He didn’t begin sufficient video games in faculty. He can’t make the reads on the line of scrimmage. I imply, he took himself out of a recreation final yr. Then you definitely suppose Anthony Richardson is completed. Hey man, Anthony, you higher get your Canadian passport since you’re gonna be enjoying within the CFL fairly quickly. That’s the damaging aspect of Anthony Richardson,” McIntyre mentioned on “The Herd.”
“You higher get your Canadian passport since you’re gonna be enjoying within the CFL fairly quickly. That is the damaging aspect of Anthony Richardson.”@jasonrmcintyre isn’t impressed with what he sees from the Colts QB pic.twitter.com/W2QwAcaV6z
— Herd w/Colin Cowherd (@TheHerd) August 8, 2025
McIntyre additionally questioned the teaching selections that led to Richardson’s newest damage. He criticized the selection to play the quarterback behind backup offensive linemen in a preseason recreation.
This uncovered Richardson to pointless danger in comparison with different groups that defend their starter with higher personnel.
The analyst talked about Richardson’s early departure from faculty as one other misstep. An NFL agent reportedly suggested him to remain one other yr and develop additional.
This might have positioned him because the No. 1 general decide in 2024, however Richardson selected the enchantment of a faster first-round contract as an alternative.
Three seasons later, that call seems questionable.
Richardson’s elite bodily instruments stay apparent, as his arm power and mobility flash potential that few quarterbacks possess.
Head coach Shane Steichen brings hope to the equation. A observe document of creating Jalen Hurts with the Philadelphia Eagles suggests he may unlock Richardson’s skills.
However the window for Richardson to show himself as a franchise quarterback continues to shut with every setback.
NEXT: Anthony Richardson Makes His Ideas Clear About Colts’ QB Competitors