When we finally found out which wine was which, we were all surprised that “wine B” was As Ever.
Ahlgrim: Oh, that’s the one that doesn’t taste like rosé! It’s weird, and I like that.
McKenzie: It was my number two favorite!
Ahlgrim: As Ever was my top in terms of what I like in a wine. I like a weirder flavor, but I think Summer Water is more rosé-y. But if I saw As Ever at the store, I would buy it again.
Pettyjohn: Me too. I would buy this again, and I think it would be nice if you paired it with fruit or cheese — that vibe. If you brought this to a party, your friends would be like, “Oh, the rosé you brought is so good. Where did you get it?”
Rollins: I would be curious to drink it in a cup, like in one of the “Love Is Blind” cups, where you can’t see what color it is, and just be like, “What does that taste like to you?”
Ahlgrim: I admire that Meghan didn’t take the easiest route. So many celebrities have an alcohol brand, so I think it was bold of her to do something that does not taste like every other rosé on the market.
Pettyjohn: If I put my Meghan Scholar hat on, I also feel this reflects her as a flavor. You think you’re going to get one thing, but then she surprises you, and it’s a really lovely flavor, even if it’s not necessarily what you were expecting.
McKenzie: It’s something that I would order again.
Pettyjohn: Me too.
McKenzie: Her rosé beats Brad Pitt’s.
Ahlgrim: 100%.